Thoughts on Christmas

With all the traditional celebrations, abuse and lawsuits of the season, a few thoughts have been buzzing me today. Thought I’d share them, and see if I can type my way to a conclusion.

  • Our Savior was most likely not born on any date anywhere close to December 25th. Does that mean that it’s wrong for a Christian to celebrate Christmas, or decorate a tree, or give gifts? Of course not. It’s never wrong to celebrate our Saviour in any way, and that we choose to schedule celebrations annually is not the same thing as observing and treating Holy Days.

    As an entertaining note from myth and history, a man known as Dionysius is the one who set the date for the celebratory feast. And the Greek god Dionysus was referred to as the twice born.

  • Some people, notably the ‘freedom from religion’ crowd, are attempting to unconstitutionaly establish atheism as the state religion. These people are religious zealots though they cavil at the term. The fact that they have no practices or worship of their own does not mean they are not religious. They assert their central tenet, “there is no god”, and demand that anyone who would gainsay them have irrefutable proof. And that is the proof of the religious aspect of their faith.

    They have no proof, yet demand proof from others. And in the absence of proof on either side, they demand that all other religious practice be shut away from them. This is religious intolerance on a scale matching Dark Ages europe or modern Islam. It does not deserve to be taken seriously, let alone supported, in civil society.

  • The war on Christmas is ongoing. It is a cultural conflict. Some who follow Christianity have a desire to keep the Christ’s Mass holy. Some others see a need to secularize the season, and eliminate all Christian symbology. I think both are wrong, and that the secularists have gone so far that they are violating the Constitutional prohibition against restrictions on the free practice of religion.
  • The substitution of a ’secular’ Happy Holidays is very amusing, given that the word ‘holiday’ derives from the phrase Holy Day. As a Christian, I am not bound to observe any particular day as holier than any other, and yet I receive wishes for a Happy Holy Day from secular sources.
  • Back to Christmas, some Christians take offence at ‘pagan’ symbols being included. I note that the Christmas celebration was not in the early church. Christ’s birth was of no importance to early Christians. About year 350, the Christmas celebration was started. There is good reason to believe that December 25th was deliberately chosen to co-opt and redefine pre-existing pagan celebrations. So, from a historical perspective, it would make as much sense to complain about Christian symbols in a pagan celebration.

    But the deeper answer is also simpler. Symbols are symbols because they have special meaning. No symbol is useful unless two people, the one using it and the one seeing it, agree on the meaning. For example, what is the inherent meaning of a green light? It has no meaning until you learn what is intended. In the same way, those ‘pagan’ symbols have had nearly all pagan meaning removed from them by time and lack of use, and they have been invested with the meaning of Christmas. Do any significant number of people today use the evergreen tree as a symbol of a rebirth of life from the death of winter? Or use the winter solstice feast to celebrate the renewal of the sun? Or have both of these become symbolic of the resurrection of Christ?

No conclusions today. But peace to you all this season, and may God be with you.



  1. sgangey said,

    December 11, 2005 @ 7:56 pm

    If the nay-sayers are not satisfied that we all have a right to our opinion and belief system, they have the right to leave our country. The First Amendment on our country’s constitution gives each of us the right to believe what we will and even be vocal about it.

    Amendment I

    Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the government for a redress of grievances.

    Atheism is classified as a religion and therefore not allowed to be established as the state religion.

    I agree the chances are real good that Jesus was not born on December 25th. It is good that the worlds relegions, that at least acknowlege he existed, have all decided on a date to celebrate his life. In all cases of relegious celebration I find that humanity finds unity in knowing that there is a power larger than ourselves and that by celebrating that we all come together as one.

    Make it a great day!

    In Light and Love!

  2. TuCents » Let’s share war on christmas. said,

    December 13, 2005 @ 1:41 am

    […] Speaking in a similar vein to Dave’s prior post concerning the war on christmas, I find it interesting that so many of our holidays are coming under attack. Is it really important that the federal government really turn a blind eye to it’s constituants merry-making? It is likely that most businesses would be closed on these holidays in any event. Most of the christians would likely not attend work, citing religious reasons. Much the same reason that sunday is largely considered a no-work day. The athiests (if you’re willing to lay this fracas at thier feet), seem to have turned a blind eye to the non-protestant-christian religions. Many Jewish holidays are printed on modern calendars, and Pagan holidays are also given a treatment (though you wouldn’t know it; it would be difficult to find a calendar that says “Solstice Tonight! All Pagans, bring out your candles!”). December itself is full of holidays. From the [sarcasm] Evil day of christmas [/sarcasm], and Yule, to Winter Equinox, Kwanzaa, Hanukkah, and (via technicality) New Years Eve. Most businesses give special dispensation over the last few weeks of December, which is usually enough to cover any of the above mentioned. You would be hard-pressed to find someone to work on that day, federal holiday aside. And if you do happen to take it off the books, just imagine how the toy and travel industries are gonna hate you. […]

RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URI

Leave a Comment

Your first comment is human moderated to reduce spam. It can take us a while (hours) to do that. Subsequent comments will appear much faster. We greatly sympathize with any frustration this causes, but given the amount of spam we have to deal with already we're not likely to change things soon.

You must be logged in to post a comment.